Prevention vs Profit: How Health Insurance Shapes the Care You Get
Episode Summary
Cole Siefer sits down with Dr. Sasha Rose, a naturopathic doctor and licensed acupuncturist who has practiced functional medicine for 20 years, to look at how the health insurance model shapes the care most people receive. Dr. Rose explains the fee-for-service structure: hospitals and providers get paid for procedures and short visits, not for healthier patients, which pushes care toward disease management and 7-minute appointments instead of root cause work. She walks through when insurance does make sense (emergencies, straightforward prescriptions, covered preventive screenings, and primary care) and where it falls short for deeper, comprehensive evaluation. A recurring theme is normal versus optimal lab ranges, illustrated with TSH, vitamin D, and ferritin. The pair compare conventional and functional approaches across gut health, weight loss and low energy, hormone therapy, joint pain, leaky gut, and mitochondrial health, and answer live viewer questions on iron, ferritin, and MTHFR testing. Dr. Rose closes with a case study of a man in his late 40s who came in on multiple medications, made gradual lifestyle changes, added targeted support, and reduced his medication list while feeling significantly better.
Key Topics
- 1
Why the fee-for-service model rewards procedures and short visits instead of patient outcomes
- 2
When it makes sense to use insurance (emergencies, prescriptions, covered screenings, primary care)
- 3
Normal versus optimal lab ranges, using TSH, vitamin D, and ferritin as examples
- 4
Lifespan versus health span as different goals of care
- 5
How insurance coverage rules shape which medications and imaging a patient can access
- 6
Conventional versus functional approaches to gut health and comprehensive stool testing
- 7
Weight loss and low energy, including GLP-1 medications used as part of a bigger plan
- 8
Hormone therapy for men and women, and looking at perimenopause rather than waiting
- 9
Leaky gut, proton pump inhibitors, and reducing polypharmacy
- 10
Mitochondrial health and MTHFR genetic testing
Quotable Moments
“It doesn't really matter how healthy a person is. They're not reimbursed with positive outcomes or healthier patients.”
“A lab's normal reference range is simply based on statistics, on the statistical norm for a certain population. I want you to have optimal health, not average.”
“I really try to stay away from transactional medicine where somebody has a complaint and I hand them a medication and I say I'll see you in 6 months. To me, that's not great care.”
“I think almost everybody who comes in here has felt dismissed, a certain level of frustration with the current system. For the most part, it's really not individual providers.”
“Anything with your health starts in the gut.”
Treatments Mentioned
FAQ
Healthcare System FAQ
Dr. Rose says insurance is a good fit for straightforward needs, like a medication you have a prescription benefit for, and for emergency care such as an accident or an ER visit. It also covers certain built-in preventive screenings like mammograms and colonoscopies when you meet the age or other criteria. She also wants patients to keep a primary care doctor for the things those offices do well.
She explains that the model is built around disease management and short visits rather than personalized, preventive care. In Maine and New Hampshire there is also a shortage of primary care providers, so access is limited and appointments are brief. Many patients feel dismissed when deeper testing is denied or when a single normal result is used to tell them they are fine.
A lab's normal reference range is based on the statistical norm for a population, so it reflects average rather than ideal. In functional medicine the target windows are often narrower, for example a tighter TSH range or higher optimal vitamin D and ferritin levels. Dr. Rose notes that someone can fall inside the normal range and still have symptoms that point to a real problem.
Insurance companies often cover only certain medications, frequently the least expensive option, so a patient's care can be shaped by their specific plan. Getting a different medication or imaging like an MRI or CT scan approved can require extra documentation, and if the patient does not meet specific criteria the request may be denied. High-quality supplements, botanicals, and lifestyle recommendations are generally not reimbursable at all.
Leaky gut refers to increased permeability in the small intestine, where the cells that should stay tightly joined begin to separate, which can trigger inflammation that shows up in the brain, joints, or skin. Dr. Rose says contributors include an inflammatory diet, a history of antibiotics, and long-term use of medications like proton pump inhibitors. She lowers inflammation, helps appropriate patients reduce those medications, and uses peptides, botanicals, and nutraceuticals to support healing over time.
Polypharmacy simply means being on many medications, often after one prescription is added to manage the side effects of another over many years. Dr. Rose says individualized care, lifestyle changes, and addressing root causes can sometimes lower doses or reduce the overall list. She describes a patient who, through gradual changes, came off a proton pump inhibitor, dropped to one blood pressure medication, and lowered his statin dose.
Related Service
Learn More
Advanced Lab Testing
Your PCP runs 10 markers. We test 80+. Full thyroid, fasting insulin, hormones, inflammatory markers, and InBody scan in South Portland, ME. 60-min review. 4.9 stars. $100 off.
